Devin Cooley

The Calgary Flames traded former Vezina Trophy runner-up Jacob Markstrom to the New Jersey Devils this summer, leaving a glaring hole in one of the most important positions in the lineup. General manager Craig Conroy expects that to elicit the biggest competition of training camp, telling Sportsnet’s Eric Francis that all of the team’s goaltenders will have a chance at the starting role. Conroy laid it out clearly, saying, “With Marky gone, the job is wide open, and these guys know this is as good an opportunity as they’re ever going to have to show what they can do and become an NHL starter.”

The competition will be fought between de facto NHL backup Daniel Vladar, top AHL goalie Dustin Wolf, and emerging prospect Devin Cooley. It’s hard to determine a favorite among the three. Vladar boasts significantly more NHL experience than the rest, recording 70 games over the last three seasons while backing up Markstrom. But his performances haven’t proven very convincing – with Vladar managing 35 wins and a .894 save percentage with the Flames. To make matters worse, Vladar is coming off a hip surgery in March, leaving him as a shaky bet to suddenly improve his performances, even in the face of opportunity.

Wolf has already bested Vladar’s stat line on a per-game basis, with eight wins and a .896 save percentage in 18 career games. Those numbers certainly aren’t convincing, but suggest some upside – especially against Devin Cooley’s meager .870 save percentage in six games with the San Jose Sharks last year.

Wolf has seemingly earned a true shot at the NHL starting role, having dominated the AHL for the last three seasons. His list of minor-league accomplishments runs on-and-on. He won the AHL’s Les Bastien ’Goaltender of the Year’ Award in both 2022 and 2023, becoming the first goalie to win in back-to-back years and just the third to win twice. He added even more hardware in the latter year, also winning the Les Cunningham ’MVP’ Award – becoming the youngest to win MVP since Jason Spezza in 2005. Those accolades have studded a career stat line of 97 wins and a .926 in 141 AHL games.

At his peak, Markstrom played a 63-game season with the Flames. That leaves a large chunk of games to be shelled out this season – and while Wolf’s precedent and Vladar’s injury seems to spell an easy decision. But with Conroy’s open-minded approach to the starting role, the duo could end up in a strict 50/50 time share, as Calgary attempts to develop a long-term starter out of one of the two.