The Pittsburgh Penguins have completed a trade of prospects with the Anaheim Ducks, per a team announcement. The Penguins are receiving the rights to 2020 fourth-round pick Thimo Nickl and are sending the rights to NCAA winger Judd Caulfield in return.
In Nickl, 21, the Penguins are acquiring a 21-year-old defenseman who was a 2020 fourth-round pick. In his draft year, the Austrian blueliner moved from the second team of Klagenfurter Athletiksport Club in his home country, where he had played parts of three seasons, to Quebec to play junior hockey with the QMJHL’s Drummondville Voltigeurs.
At that point in his career, Nickl had already played 55 games in the AlpsHL, a professional league where he was competing against men. As a result, playing junior hockey in the QMJHL proved to be a less challenging task for Nickl, who ranked second among Voltigeurs blueliners in scoring with 39 points in 58 games.
After being drafted, Nickl joined the SHL’s Rogle BK’s youth system, and managed to play 15 games in Sweden’s top division with the club. Nickl was then loaned to AIK in September of 2021, a club in the second-tier HockeyAllsvenskan, and scored 10 points in 38 games there.
In early 2022 Nickl’s move to AIK was made permanent, and this season he played a regular role for the club, scoring eight points in 47 games to go alongside 69 penalty minutes. AIK failed to make a promotion push but Nickl ultimately further established himself as a professional player.
By acquiring Nickl’s rights, the Penguins now have until June 1st, 2024 to decide whether to give Nickl an entry-level deal before his rights expire, according to CapFriendly. It’s a more extended timeframe compared to the one they had with Caulfield, who can hit the open market on August 15th.
It’s definitely possible that the Penguins had an indication from Caulfield that he would not be signing with them before that date, prompting this trade, or it’s also possible that the team simply wasn’t interested in signing Caulfield and chose to leverage the remaining months of exclusivity they had with him in order to acquire a prospect they were more interested in.
For the Ducks, this trade is similarly a potential indication that they were not interested in signing Nickl to an entry-level deal before next summer, although it could also be a sign that they are simply more interested in adding Caulfield than they were of signing Nickl.
Caulfield, 22, is a 2019 fifth-round pick who has played the last four seasons at the University of North Dakota. The big six-foot-three winger is a product of the U.S. National Team Development Program and has scored 39 points over the last two seasons.
With his rights now acquired, the Ducks will likely get to work on trying to negotiate an entry-level deal with the winger, who would likely begin his professional career developing his game in the minors.