Headlines

  • Avalanche, Jets, Lightning Interested In Jonathan Toews
  • Stars Reportedly Dialing Back Efforts To Trade Jason Robertson
  • Updates On Sam Bennett, Aaron Ekblad
  • Kings’ Anže Kopitar Wins 2024-25 Lady Byng Trophy
  • Ducks Acquire Chris Kreider From Rangers
  • Multiple Teams Interested In Sabres’ Bowen Byram
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • MLB Trade Rumors
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors

Pro Hockey Rumors

  • Home
  • Teams
    • Atlantic
      • Boston Bruins
      • Buffalo Sabres
      • Detroit Red Wings
      • Florida Panthers
      • Montreal Canadiens
      • Ottawa Senators
      • Tampa Bay Lightning
      • Toronto Maple Leafs
    • Central
      • Chicago Blackhawks
      • Colorado Avalanche
      • Dallas Stars
      • Minnesota Wild
      • Nashville Predators
      • St. Louis Blues
      • Utah Mammoth
      • Winnipeg Jets
    • Metropolitan
      • Carolina Hurricanes
      • Columbus Blue Jackets
      • New Jersey Devils
      • New York Islanders
      • New York Rangers
      • Philadelphia Flyers
      • Pittsburgh Penguins
      • Washington Capitals
    • Pacific
      • Anaheim Ducks
      • Calgary Flames
      • Edmonton Oilers
      • Los Angeles Kings
      • San Jose Sharks
      • Seattle Kraken
      • Vancouver Canucks
      • Vegas Golden Knights
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Partners
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
Go To MLB Trade Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Vezina Finalists Announced; Is The Evaluation Process Flawed?

April 17, 2018 at 7:27 pm CDT | by Zach Leach 21 Comments

The NHL has announced the three finalists for the Vezina Award, given each year to the league’s best goaltender, as voted on by the league’s general managers. Vying for the trophy at the NHL Awards in Las Vegas this June will be the Winnipeg Jets’ Connor Hellebuyck, the Nashville Predators’ Pekka Rinne, and the Tampa Bay Lightning’s Andrei Vasilevskiy. This is the first nomination for Hellebuyck and Vasilevskiy, while Rinne has previously been up for the award three times.

At first glance, the three nominees are not surprising. All three have had great seasons and are clearly among the top goaltenders in the league. However, hockey analytics guru Rob Vollman makes a pretty good case for why the evaluation process my be flawed. As Vollman points out, the only category in which the trio were tops in the league is wins, a statistic based entirely off of team performance, not individual performance. Hellebuyck and Vasilevskiy led the league with 44 wins, while Rinne was right behind with 42.  Yet, only Rinne was top three in the league among goalies with 41+ starts in save percentage, quality starts percentage, and goals saved above average, Vollman’s stats of choice. By those standards of evaluation, Vasilevskiy should have been nowhere near Vezina contention. Instead, Vollman’s poster boy for proper evaluation is the Anaheim Ducks’ John Gibson, who was a top-four finisher in each of those three categories and a top-ten finisher in wins. Also garnering some more attentions should have been the Vegas Golden Knights’ Marc-Andre Fleury and the Arizona Coyotes’ Antti Raanta, both of whom were excellent statistically, but lacked the number of starts and wins that are apparently requisite for Vezina contention in today’s NHL.

It’s no surprise that the three contenders for best goaltender are who they are. However, that doesn’t mean it’s correct, especially in a season so many other obvious choices. General managers surely do not evaluate goalies based on wins alone when evaluating them for acquisition, so why does a clearly-flawed statistic hold so much weight in the Vezina race? It’s a question worth asking and Vollman’s reaction, as well as others’, may change the voting results come next season. In the meantime, look for Rinne to finally take home the hardware this year in his fourth try, a result that was likely even with proper evaluation.

Share 0 Retweet 0 Send via email

Anaheim Ducks| Nashville Predators| Tampa Bay Lightning| Utah Mammoth| Vegas Golden Knights| Winnipeg Jets Andrei Vasilevskiy| Antti Raanta| Connor Hellebuyck| John Gibson| Las Vegas| Marc-Andre Fleury| NHL Awards| Pekka Rinne

Rangers Closing In On Swedish Forward Michael Lindqvist
Main
Dennis Cholowski Joins Grand Rapids Griffins
View Comments (21)

Comments

  1. natesp4

    7 years ago

    I’d even vote for Crawford. Putting up those goalie numbers on an awful team is impressive.

    Reply
    • Hockeysense93

      7 years ago

      I would normally agree, but unfortunately Crawford was hurt for a huge portion of the season.

      1
      Reply
    • ericl

      7 years ago

      Crawford missed too many games. He only played 33 games. Can’t win the Vezina playing that little

      Reply
      • natesp4

        7 years ago

        Yeah, fair. Didn’t quite notice he missed that many.

        Reply
  2. Hockeysense93

    7 years ago

    Like a lot of other “voted” awards…this is always with a grain of salt. These are on top teams that are expected to show something…playoffs included. You can’t have a Vezina trophy winner that happens to be the best player on a bad team can you? Haha. It’s a fixed trophy that has politics hooked to it. I can almost guarantee that Rinne will “finally” win it, being the big favourite compared to the others. It’s kind of like the Selke as well…you don’t win it on a season stat alone…you need to put in your time and keep certain values up for a few seasons. Same with the Norris in some respects as well.

    Reply
    • cybrpete

      7 years ago

      An unfortunate situation but accurate observation on your part. What happens if a guy has one great year? Nothing.

      Reply
    • jd396

      7 years ago

      The Rafael Palmeiro rule. If something is possible, eventually it will happen. Being technically eligible for the award is all that is required to win it sometimes.

      Reply
      • Hockeysense93

        7 years ago

        This is true. It took Lidström 3 years in a row of being runner up, before winning it the next 6 out of 7 years lol. Those 3 years, it was even controversial somewhat that he wasn’t winning it.

        Reply
    • ericl

      7 years ago

      How does Rinne or Hellebuyck being finalists have politics hooked to it? Both of those goalies have been incredible all year. Sure, Rinne has a great team in front of him, but there were plenty of games where he stole the game for his team. His numbers speak for themselves. He certainly is a worthy finalist & would be a worthy winner. Goaltending has been a weakness for Winnipeg. Hellebuyck changed that this season. He has settled that team down & gave them great goaltending to go along with their offense. His numbers are also finalist caliber. He too is a worthy finalist & would be a worthy winner. There is no politics involved in either player being finalists. It isn’t fixed if either one of them win it. Rinne & Hellebuyck have been the best goalies in the league. That isn’t political.

      Reply
  3. Hockeysense93

    7 years ago

    Why there isn’t an actual “Defensemen” award by now is beyond me. Like the best defensive defenceman? lol

    Reply
    • diller79

      7 years ago

      There is. It’s called the Norris Trophy

      Reply
      • tim2686

        7 years ago

        hahahahahaha…..it usually goes to the top scoring defenseman or the most talked about. looking at you PK.

        Reply
        • Hockeysense93

          7 years ago

          You got what I was putting down haha

          Reply
        • ericl

          7 years ago

          Don’t forget Erik Karlsson. The first Norris he won was solely on his offensive stats. He was 6th on his team among defensemen in penalty kill time that year & didn’t play against the opposing teams players. That isn’t Norris worthy

          Reply
  4. cybrpete

    7 years ago

    I won’t make the argument that he deserves the Vezina, but Gibson is an athletic goalie who has been the Ducks’ best player this year.

    Reply
    • Hockeysense93

      7 years ago

      I think the only knock against Gibson is that he’s injury prone. One of these years, he’s gonna play the whole season…and win it!

      Reply
  5. diller79

    7 years ago

    Bobrovsky should win the Vezina. He was the main reason Columbus was even relevant this season and they made the playoffs

    Reply
  6. ericl

    7 years ago

    I can’t argue with any of the three. I expected them to be the finalists and they are all deserving. Raanta was not good for the first third of the season. He played well after the All-Star break, but those were all meaningless games for Arizona because the Coyotes were long out of it. Fleury only played 46 games because of injury. While his numbers are great, it is hard to give him a finalist spot over Rinne, Hellebuyck or Vasilesky who played the great the whole season. Rinne & Hellebuyck’s numbers are better than Gibson’s & Bobrovsky’s. Vasilesky has a higher GAA & a lower save % than both Gibson & Bobrovsky, but has more wins & shutouts. Rinne & Hellebuyck are no-brainers as finalists. If you want to argue against one, it would be Vasilesky.

    Reply
  7. 66TheNumberOfTheBest

    7 years ago

    Moneypuckers so desperately want to be Moneyballers but they are not. They are basically doing a rain dance with numbers.

    Hockey has too many variables to be accurately measured by what currently passes for hockey sabremetrics.

    1
    Reply
    • natesp4

      7 years ago

      I’d hardly call the stats he cited as sabremetrics. He’s just saying let’s focus less on Wins which is a silly stat anyways

      Reply
  8. HalosFan8

    7 years ago

    Rinne should finally win it, but nice to see Gibson get a little love. He kept the team alive all year. His playoff career hasn’t been pretty but he will be a dominant goalie for years to come if he can avoid all the minor injuries that he rakes up each year.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

    Top Stories

    Avalanche, Jets, Lightning Interested In Jonathan Toews

    Stars Reportedly Dialing Back Efforts To Trade Jason Robertson

    Updates On Sam Bennett, Aaron Ekblad

    Kings’ Anže Kopitar Wins 2024-25 Lady Byng Trophy

    Ducks Acquire Chris Kreider From Rangers

    Multiple Teams Interested In Sabres’ Bowen Byram

    Mario Lemieux-Led Group Interested In Stake In Penguins

    Cale Makar Wins 2025 Norris Trophy

    Blue Jackets Expected To Pursue Mitch Marner

    Canadiens’ Lane Hutson Wins 2025 Calder Trophy

    Recent

    Penguins Re-Sign Bokondji Imama To One-Year Contract

    Jaromir Jagr Hopes To Play 38th Professional Season

    Ducks Sign Lucas Pettersson To Entry-Level Contract

    Blackhawks Trade Rights To Victor Soderstrom To Bruins

    Penguins Sign Melvin Fernstrom To Three-Year, Entry-Level Contract

    Update On Minnesota Wild’s Marco Rossi

    Friedman: Kings Could Consider Trading Jordan Spence

    NHL Announces 2024-25 All-Star Teams

    Avalanche, Jets, Lightning Interested In Jonathan Toews

    Stars Reportedly Dialing Back Efforts To Trade Jason Robertson

    Rumors By Team

    Rumors By Team

    • Avalanche Rumors
    • Blackhawks Rumors
    • Blue Jackets Rumors
    • Blues Rumors
    • Bruins Rumors
    • Canadiens Rumors
    • Canucks Rumors
    • Capitals Rumors
    • Devils Rumors
    • Ducks Rumors
    • Flames Rumors
    • Flyers Rumors
    • Golden Knights Rumors
    • Hurricanes Rumors
    • Islanders Rumors
    • Jets Rumors
    • Kings Rumors
    • Kraken Rumors
    • Lightning Rumors
    • Mammoth Rumors
    • Maple Leafs Rumors
    • Oilers Rumors
    • Panthers Rumors
    • Penguins Rumors
    • Predators Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Red Wings Rumors
    • Sabres Rumors
    • Senators Rumors
    • Sharks Rumors
    • Stars Rumors
    • Wild Rumors

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • Sam Bennett Rumors
    • Nikolaj Ehlers Rumors
    • Mitch Marner Rumors
    • Marco Rossi Rumors

    Pro Hockey Rumors Features

    Pro Hockey Rumors Features

    • Support Pro Hockey Rumors And Go Ad-Free
    • 2025 Free Agent Focus Series
    • 2025 Offseason Checklist Series
    • 2025 NHL Free Agent List
    • 2026 NHL Free Agent List
    • Active Roster Tracker
    • Coaching Staff Directory
    • Draft Order 2025
    • Offseason Trade Tracker
    • Pro Hockey Rumors On X
    • Pro Hockey Rumors Polls
    • Waiver Claims 2024-25

     

     

     

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives

    PHR Info

    • About
    • Privacy Policy
    • Commenting Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    Pro Hockey Rumors is not affiliated with National Hockey League, NHL or NHL.com

    scroll to top

    Register

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version