Islanders Sign Josh Kotai To Two-Year Contract
The Islanders announced they’ve signed college free agent goaltender Josh Kotai to a two-year, entry-level contract. Terms were not disclosed, although the deal presumably begins next season. If he wants to play pro hockey this year, he’ll have to sign a tryout with the Isles’ AHL affiliate in Bridgeport.
Kotai, 23, turns pro after helping author one of the best stories in Division I hockey this year. The 23-year-old has been with Augustana University since its inception as a DI program in 2023, committing there after playing for the Battlefords North Stars of the junior ‘A’ league in Saskatchewan. He took over the starter’s crease as a sophomore last season and, this year as a junior, nearly helped backstop them to an at-large bid to the national tournament. Augustana did end up 15th in the year-end NPI rankings with an overall record of 22-11-4, but with lower-ranked Merrimack and Bentley both winning autobids as a result of their conference championships, Augustana fell just short of the cutoff.
The South Dakota university’s success over the past two years has fallen mostly on Kotai’s shoulders. The British Columbia native churned out a .931 SV%, 2.17 GAA, eight shutouts, and a 39-30-9 record in 79 career outings for the Vikings. That includes a sub-2.00 GAA in each of his two seasons as a starter. Only one goalie in college hockey (min. 10 games) had a better save percentage than Kotai’s .938 mark this season – Denver rookie backup Johnny Hicks, who’s posted a .958 mark in 17 outings entering tournament play.
At 6’1″ and 165 lbs, Kotai lacks size. It’s still hard to make the argument that he wasn’t the best undrafted goaltender available in this year’s NCAA free agent market, given what he’s done for the Vikings to date. He joins the Islanders’ pipeline, where he will challenge as the highest-ceiling option in the organization to support Ilya Sorokin long-term. None of their current AHL options are particularly inspiring, although 2024 fourth-round pick Dmitri Gamzin has now emerged as the starter for Russia’s CSKA Moscow with some great numbers. It’s unclear when, if at all, he plans to come stateside, but he’ll remain in Russia through at least the end of his current contract, which ends in 2027-28.