Veteran defenseman Darnell Nurse is “headed for a breakup” with the Edmonton Oilers, Mark Spector of Sportsnet reported today. Spector cited conversations with “several current and former [Oilers] employees” that have indicated the Oilers “are ready and willing to trade Nurse as soon as they are able.” 
Spector also reported that Oilers GM Stan Bowman will meet with Nurse in the coming days to discuss his future plans. Nurse holds full control over whether or not he’ll be traded this summer.
The $9.25MM AAV contract Nurse signed on August 2021 contains a full no-movement clause for its first five seasons, meaning Nurse can block any transaction that would send him to another team through the end of next season.
As a result, Spector noted that if Nurse indicates to Bowman in their upcoming conversation that he would like to remain an Oiler for another year, “trade talk will be shelved and the team will welcome him back for one more year.”
But the Oilers’ preference is to trade Nurse before the start of next season. According to Spector, this is not a sudden development, but rather something the Oilers have been quietly laying the groundwork to do for more than a year.
Spector reported that the Oilers have been “open to moving Nurse since the conclusion of the 2025 Stanley Cup Final” and that Nurse’s form had become such a concern during the 2024 Stanley Cup Final that there were even discussions of healthy scratching him during the series. The Oilers fell into a 3-0 hole against the Florida Panthers that year, but rattled off three straight wins to tie the series before falling in a close seventh game.
Edmonton is entering an extremely important offseason after a disappointing first-round playoff exit. Comments to the media made by franchise center Connor McDavid after the team’s loss to the Anaheim Ducks shed some light on the task Bowman faces: he simply has to make substantial upgrades to the team’s roster, or they risk losing the confidence of the face of their franchise. McDavid signed a two-year contract extension in October, meaning he is only committed to the Oilers through the end of the 2027-28 campaign.
Unfortunately for Bowman, he doesn’t have a huge amount of financial flexibility to work with this summer. The team is projected to have just over $14.5MM in space according to PuckPedia, but that number is likely to decline quickly if the Oilers re-sign some of their pending free agents, such as Jason Dickinson or Connor Murphy.
Moving Nurse alone would clear $9.25MM off the Oilers’ books, creating a substantial amount of cap space for Bowman to work with. But the fact that Nurse has full control over his playing future for one more season will make finding a deal difficult – if not impossible.
The issue for Nurse and the Oilers isn’t that Nurse is in any way a bad player. He was Edmonton’s No. 2 defenseman in terms of ice time last season, averaging just under 21:00 per game. The 31-year-old is a big, athletic defenseman (6’4″, 215 pounds) who pairs mobility with physicality and the ability to provide secondary offense – around 35 points per season but as many as 43. Nurse’s offensive numbers declined this past season, as his 24 points were his lowest in a season since 2017-18. But he still played significant minutes for the team, minutes that would need to be replaced if the Oilers trade Nurse.
The bet Bowman would be making in any Nurse deal would be that he could replace the tough minutes Nurse soaks up for the Oilers with another defenseman, at a cheaper rate. There’s no guarantee he can do that, of course, but with limited options to create cap space, it seems the Oilers have identified trading Nurse as a path they want to try to go down.
If Nurse does block a deal this summer, it seems overwhelmingly likely that the Oilers would pursue trading him next summer, when his NMC becomes a 10-team no-trade list. So, while Nurse does have the leverage of being able to block a trade, he may only end up postponing his exit from Edmonton.
The Oilers could therefore argue that he is better-served working with the team to facilitate a trade this summer, where he would be able to exercise control over the process and select a preferred landing spot.
Next summer, a little over two-thirds of the league would open up as possible destinations to receive Nurse. But he may also be willing to accept the risk of being traded next summer to a sub-optimal destination in exchange for the chance to stay in Edmonton. With one more year in Edmonton, Nurse could push for a Stanley Cup with McDavid, Leon Draisaitl, and the other teammates he has shared the ice with for more than a decade.
It’s not clear what Nurse will choose, or what route he’ll elect to take with his playing future. What is clear is what the Oilers want, which according to Spector’s report is a divorce from one of the long-term staples of their blueline.
Photos courtesy of Perry Nelson-Imagn Images
lol
Nobody is just taking Nurse’s contract out. The Oilers will have to retain some salary or take a bad contract back or provide a sweetner
Now trade for Saros and sign Berube.
If Saros wants to go to Edmonton. He’s got a no-movement clause & has said he doesn’t want to leave Nashville
I’m getting this immense feeling of Deja Vu’ all over again. They have this plan every year. And every year they find out NOBODY WANTS HIM! At any price! He’s Bad, Expensive, And an anchor for the franchise. Get used to it, Might make it easier to swallow.
Skeptical as to how this could get done and actually make them any better. Clearly not worth near his contract but as the article notes they have very little space and clearly have to eat a bunch of the contract. I don’t know how much “better” they’re going to be by whoever they add in for 2mm a year.
The only way this gets across the finish line is if they can move him for a Brent Seabrook type contract where the guy is never going to play again and they can put him on IR. Ar there any more of those lying around? It would actually be hilarious because Bowman was the Dumb A__ that gave out that contract.
They might need to move him just to change the story. Nurse is flawed but he seems to get blamed for more things than he deserves, just like Skinner. I thought they were working on a Reilly for Nurse deal before, maybe they can bring that one back to life.
Wonder if they would retain and take Ryan graves off our hands (penguins)
SJS for future considerations..?
Unless some team needs to reach the cap floor, good luck moving that contract.