Headlines

  • Oilers’ Ryan Nugent-Hopkins Uncertain For Game 3
  • Maple Leafs Hire Derek Lalonde As Assistant Coach
  • Avalanche’s Logan O’Connor Out 5-6 Months Following Hip Surgery
  • Lightning Hire Dan Hinote As Assistant Coach
  • Stars Fire Pete DeBoer
  • Rangers Hire David Quinn, Joe Sacco As Assistant Coaches
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • MLB Trade Rumors
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors

Pro Hockey Rumors

  • Home
  • Teams
    • Atlantic
      • Boston Bruins
      • Buffalo Sabres
      • Detroit Red Wings
      • Florida Panthers
      • Montreal Canadiens
      • Ottawa Senators
      • Tampa Bay Lightning
      • Toronto Maple Leafs
    • Central
      • Chicago Blackhawks
      • Colorado Avalanche
      • Dallas Stars
      • Minnesota Wild
      • Nashville Predators
      • St. Louis Blues
      • Utah Mammoth
      • Winnipeg Jets
    • Metropolitan
      • Carolina Hurricanes
      • Columbus Blue Jackets
      • New Jersey Devils
      • New York Islanders
      • New York Rangers
      • Philadelphia Flyers
      • Pittsburgh Penguins
      • Washington Capitals
    • Pacific
      • Anaheim Ducks
      • Calgary Flames
      • Edmonton Oilers
      • Los Angeles Kings
      • San Jose Sharks
      • Seattle Kraken
      • Vancouver Canucks
      • Vegas Golden Knights
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Partners
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
Go To MLB Trade Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

List Of NHL Quarter-Century Teams

January 31, 2025 at 11:25 am CDT | by Josh Erickson 101 Comments

Throughout the middle of the season, the NHL is unveiling Quarter-Century Teams for all 32 franchises, plus the now-defunct Coyotes. Each club is represented by a first and second team of six players – three forwards, two defensemen and one goalie – who played for the franchise after Jan. 1, 2000. The first and second teams were selected by broadcasters and national, local, and NHL.com writers who covered the respective teams and some former players. The six players voted to each First Team will be on the ballot for the NHL All-Quarter-Century Team and will be chosen via a fan vote starting in February.

Back in December, PHR’s Josh Erickson took a crack at predicting how each franchise’s teams would shake out. You can cross-check his projections against the actual results.


Utah Hockey Club (Jan. 31)

First Team

F Logan Cooley
F Dylan Guenther
F Clayton Keller
D Michael Kesselring
D Mikhail Sergachev
G Karel Vejmelka

Second Team

F Alexander Kerfoot
F Jack McBain
F Nick Schmaltz
D Ian Cole
D Olli Määttä
G Connor Ingram

Edmonton Oilers (Jan. 30)

First Team

F Leon Draisaitl
F Connor McDavid
F Ryan Nugent-Hopkins
D Evan Bouchard
D Darnell Nurse
G Dwayne Roloson

Second Team

F Aleš Hemský
F Shawn Horcoff
F Ryan Smyth
D Mattias Ekholm
D Jason Smith
G Tommy Salo

Los Angeles Kings (Jan. 29)

First Team

F Dustin Brown
F Jeff Carter
F Anze Kopitar
D Drew Doughty
D Alec Martinez
G Jonathan Quick

Second Team

F Adrian Kempe
F Žigmund Pálffy
F Justin Williams
D Mattias Norström
D Lubomir Visnovsky
G Felix Potvin

Nashville Predators (Jan. 29)

First Team

F Mike Fisher
F Filip Forsberg
F Paul Kariya
D Roman Josi
D Shea Weber
G Pekka Rinne

Second Team

F Ryan Johansen
F David Legwand
F Steve Sullivan
D Mattias Ekholm
D Kimmo Timonen
G Juuse Saros

Tampa Bay Lightning (Jan. 28)

First Team

F Nikita Kucherov
F Steven Stamkos
F Martin St. Louis
D Dan Boyle
D Victor Hedman
G Andrei Vasilevskiy

Second Team

F Vincent Lecavalier
F Brayden Point
F Brad Richards
D Pavel Kubina
D Ryan McDonagh
G Ben Bishop

San Jose Sharks (Jan. 27)

First Team

F Patrick Marleau
F Joe Pavelski
F Joe Thornton
D Brent Burns
D Marc-Édouard Vlasic
G Evgeni Nabokov

Second Team

F Logan Couture
F Tomáš Hertl
F Owen Nolan
D Dan Boyle
D Erik Karlsson
G Martin Jones

New York Rangers (Jan. 26)

First Team

F Chris Kreider
F Artemi Panarin
F Mika Zibanejad
D Adam Fox
D Ryan McDonagh
G Henrik Lundqvist

Second Team

F Jaromir Jagr
F Derek Stepan
F Mats Zuccarello
D Dan Girardi
D Marc Staal
G Igor Shesterkin

Ottawa Senators (Jan. 25)

First Team

F Daniel Alfredsson
F Dany Heatley
F Jason Spezza
D Erik Karlsson
D Wade Redden
G Craig Anderson

Second Team

F Marian Hossa
F Mark Stone
F Brady Tkachuk
D Zdeno Chara
D Chris Phillips
G Patrick Lalime

New York Islanders (Jan. 24)

First Team

F Josh Bailey
F Brock Nelson
F John Tavares
D Nick Leddy
D Adam Pelech
G Ilya Sorokin

Second Team

F Mathew Barzal
F Anders Lee
F Frans Nielsen
D Kenny Jönsson
D Ryan Pulock
G Semyon Varlamov

Detroit Red Wings (Jan. 23)

First Team

F Pavel Datsyuk
F Steve Yzerman
F Henrik Zetterberg
D Niklas Kronwall
D Nicklas Lidström
G Chris Osgood

Second Team

F Sergei Fedorov
F Dylan Larkin
F Brendan Shanahan
D Chris Chelios
D Brian Rafalski
G Dominik Hašek

New Jersey Devils (Jan. 22)

First Team

F Patrik Elias
F Jack Hughes
F Zach Parise
D Scott Niedermayer
D Scott Stevens
G Martin Brodeur

Second Team

F Scott Gomez
F Jamie Langenbrunner
F Travis Zajac
D Andy Greene
D Brian Rafalski
G Cory Schneider

Vancouver Canucks (Jan. 21)

First Team

F Markus Näslund
F Daniel Sedin
F Henrik Sedin
D Alexander Edler
D Quinn Hughes
G Roberto Luongo

Second Team

F Ryan Kesler
F J.T. Miller
F Elias Pettersson
D Kevin Bieksa
D Mattias Öhlund
G Thatcher Demko

Colorado Avalanche (Jan. 20)

First Team

F Peter Forsberg
F Nathan MacKinnon
F Joe Sakic
D Adam Foote
D Cale Makar
G Patrick Roy

Second Team

F Milan Hejduk
F Gabriel Landeskog
F Mikko Rantanen
D Rob Blake
D Erik Johnson
G Semyon Varlamov

Montreal Canadiens (Jan. 19)

First Team

F Tomáš Plekanec
F Alex Kovalev
F Saku Koivu
D Andrei Markov
D Shea Weber
G Carey Price

Second Team

F Brendan Gallagher
F Nick Suzuki
F Max Pacioretty
D Sheldon Souray
D P.K. Subban
G José Théodore

Washington Capitals (Jan. 18)

First Team

F Nicklas Bäckström
F T.J. Oshie
F Alex Ovechkin
D John Carlson
D Mike Green
G Braden Holtby

Second Team

F Peter Bondra
F Evgeny Kuznetsov
F Tom Wilson
D Sergei Gonchar
D Dmitry Orlov
G Olaf Kölzig

Carolina Hurricanes (Jan. 17)

First Team

F Sebastian Aho
F Rod Brind’Amour
F Eric Staal
D Jaccob Slavin
D Glen Wesley
G Cam Ward

Second Team

F Ron Francis
F Jordan Staal
F Justin Williams
D Justin Faulk
D Bret Hedican
G Artūrs Irbe

Dallas Stars (Jan. 16)

First Team

F Jamie Benn
F Jere Lehtinen
F Mike Modano
D Miro Heiskanen
D Sergei Zubov
G Marty Turco

Second Team

F Brenden Morrow
F Joe Pavelski
F Tyler Seguin
D John Klingberg
D Esa Lindell
G Ed Belfour

Buffalo Sabres (Jan. 15)

First Team

F Daniel Brière
F Jason Pominville
F Thomas Vanek
D Brian Campbell
D Rasmus Dahlin
G Ryan Miller

Second Team

F Chris Drury
F Derek Roy
F Jack Eichel
D Jay McKee
D Tyler Myers
G Dominik Hašek

Boston Bruins (Jan. 14)

First Team

F Patrice Bergeron
F David Krejčí
F Brad Marchand
D Zdeno Chára
D Charlie McAvoy
G Tim Thomas

Second Team

F Milan Lucic
F David Pastrňák
F Joe Thornton
D Torey Krug
D Dennis Seidenberg
G Tuukka Rask

Philadelphia Flyers (Jan. 13)

First Team

F Simon Gagné
F Claude Giroux
F Mike Richards
D Éric Desjardins
D Kimmo Timonen
G Roman Čechmánek

Second Team

F Daniel Brière
F Sean Couturier
F Jakub Voráček
D Chris Pronger
D Ivan Provorov
G Brian Boucher

Calgary Flames (Jan. 11)

First Team

F Johnny Gaudreau
F Jarome Iginla
F Matthew Tkachuk
D Mark Giordano
D Robyn Regehr
G Miikka Kiprusoff

Second Team

F Mikael Backlund
F Craig Conroy
F Sean Monahan
D Rasmus Andersson
D Dion Phaneuf
G Jacob Markstrom

Winnipeg Jets (Jan. 10)

First Team

F Ilya Kovalchuk
F Mark Scheifele
F Blake Wheeler
D Dustin Byfuglien
D Josh Morrissey
G Connor Hellebuyck

Second Team

F Kyle Connor
F Nikolaj Ehlers
F Bryan Little
D Toby Enström
D Jacob Trouba
G Ondřej Pavelec

Pittsburgh Penguins (Jan. 9)

First Team

F Sidney Crosby
F Jake Guentzel
F Evgeni Malkin
D Sergei Gonchar
D Kris Letang
G Marc-André Fleury

Second Team

F Phil Kessel
F Chris Kunitz
F Mario Lemieux
D Brian Dumoulin
D Brooks Orpik
G Matt Murray

Minnesota Wild (Jan. 7)

First Team

F Marián Gáborík
F Kirill Kaprizov
F Mikko Koivu
D Jonas Brodin
D Jared Spurgeon
G Niklas Bäckström

Second Team

F Andrew Brunette
F Joel Eriksson Ek
F Zach Parise
D Nick Schultz
D Ryan Suter
G Devan Dubnyk

Seattle Kraken (Jan. 6)

First Team

F Jordan Eberle
F Yanni Gourde
F Jared McCann
D Vince Dunn
D Adam Larsson
G Joey Daccord

Second Team

F Matty Beniers
F Oliver Bjorkstrand
F Jaden Schwartz
D Brandon Montour
D Jamie Oleksiak
G Philipp Grubauer

Anaheim Ducks (Jan. 5)

First Team

F Corey Perry
F Ryan Getzlaf
F Teemu Selänne
D Scott Niedermayer
D Cam Fowler
G Jean-Sébastien Giguère

Second Team

F Paul Kariya
F Bobby Ryan
F Jakob Silfverberg
D Chris Pronger
D François Beauchemin
G John Gibson

Toronto Maple Leafs (Jan. 4)

First Team

F Mitch Marner
F Auston Matthews
F Mats Sundin
D Tomáš Kaberle
D Morgan Rielly
G Ed Belfour

Second Team

F Phil Kessel
F William Nylander
F John Tavares
D Bryan McCabe
D Dion Phaneuf
G Curtis Joseph

Florida Panthers (Jan. 3)

First Team

F Aleksander Barkov
F Jonathan Huberdeau
F Matthew Tkachuk
D Aaron Ekblad
D Gustav Forsling
G Roberto Luongo

Second Team

F Pavel Bure
F Olli Jokinen
F Sam Reinhart
D Jay Bouwmeester
D Róbert Švehla
G Sergei Bobrovsky

Columbus Blue Jackets (Jan. 2)

First Team

F Cam Atkinson
F Rick Nash
F Artemi Panarin
D Seth Jones
D Zach Werenski
G Sergei Bobrovsky

Second Team

F Nick Foligno
F Johnny Gaudreau
F Boone Jenner
D David Savard
D Fedor Tyutin
D Steve Mason

Arizona Coyotes (Jan. 1)

First Team

F Shane Doan
F Clayton Keller
F Radim Vrbata
D Oliver Ekman-Larsson
D Keith Yandle
G Mike Smith

Second Team

F Martin Hanzal
F Jeremy Roenick
F Nick Schmaltz
D Zbyněk Michálek
D Teppo Numminen
G Ilya Bryzgalov

Chicago Blackhawks (Dec. 31)

First Team

F Patrick Kane
F Patrick Sharp
F Jonathan Toews
D Duncan Keith
D Brent Seabrook
G Corey Crawford

Second Team

F Alex DeBrincat
F Marián Hossa
F Brandon Saad
D Brian Campbell
D Niklas Hjalmarsson
G Jocelyn Thibault

St. Louis Blues (Dec. 30)

First Team

F Alexander Steen
F Vladimir Tarasenko
F Keith Tkachuk
D Alex Pietrangelo
D Chris Pronger
G Jordan Binnington

Second Team

F David Backes
F Ryan O’Reilly
F David Perron
D Al MacInnis
D Colton Parayko
G Brian Elliott

Share 0 Retweet 0 Send via email

Quarter-Century Teams

NHL, NHLPA Release Salary Cap Figures Through 2027-28
Main
Utah’s Logan Cooley Out Indefinitely With Lower-Body Injury
View Comments (101)

Comments

  1. wreckage

    5 months ago

    The link to cross check the prediction leads to a x post about some kid.

    And how does Roenick get voted to the Arizona team with his 2.5 seasons with the yotes in the timeframe?

    2
    Reply
    • Josh Erickson

      5 months ago

      That link is fixed. And you’re not alone in your puzzlement.

      3
      Reply
  2. Don's Cherry

    5 months ago

    Hossa imminently superior to Sharp!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    5
    Reply
    • M34

      5 months ago

      ‘Imminently’ doesn’t fit there, I think you meant Immensely. But I get your point. Must mean he’s going in with Ottawa?

      3
      Reply
    • M34

      5 months ago

      Ah. Never mind. He’s on team 2.
      In that case I agree completely

      Reply
    • retsubllab

      5 months ago

      0 for 2, whiz kids. The word is ’eminently’ -meaning ‘to a notable degree’

      1
      Reply
    • M34

      5 months ago

      That could fit too

      Reply
  3. PyramidHeadcrab

    5 months ago

    No offense to Nick Foligno and Boone Jenner, but the fact that either of these guys made the list really underscores just how badly CBJ has been hurting for some true star talent up front. Gaudreau was on the precipice of getting there, but some drunk-driver POS had to stop that…

    6
    Reply
    • 66TheNumberOfTheBest

      5 months ago

      Fedor Tyutin.

      Him over Jaroslav Spacek must have been a tough call.

      Joking aside, this is some serious Jack Johnson erasure.

      1
      Reply
  4. 8EL8

    5 months ago

    More meaningless NHL content compiled, And published by an overzealous intern.

    2
    Reply
  5. JP8

    5 months ago

    Wow… That Chicago lineup, first team and parts of the second played together for years!

    1
    Reply
  6. dano62

    5 months ago

    Youch! Forsling makes Panthers first team, one of many gifts of Benning that haunt the Canucks still (guenther will too)…

    1
    Reply
  7. kingsfan1968

    5 months ago

    Al Macinnis 2nd Team? Wow!

    Reply
    • wreckage

      5 months ago

      Al only played 3.5 season this century.

      Reply
  8. wreckage

    5 months ago

    Knew Pronger would make at least 1 list.

    1
    Reply
    • wreckage

      5 months ago

      Make it 2 now. Although making the Flyers seems like a joke. with his 145 game career in Phili.

      Reply
    • siddfinch1079

      5 months ago

      Three total with ANA, STL & PHI. Not sure if his one year with EDM is better than the rest of their Dmen though to make it 4 for 4…

      Reply
    • frozenaquatic

      5 months ago

      Yeah, Pronger on Philly is so sus — only had one good year. Should have been Gostisbehere imho, who had four good impactful seasons (and two Covid seasons), but would have accepted Mark Streit, Kim Johnsson, Joni Pitkanen, or Matt Carle, who all had at least 3 good seasons with the Flyers.

      Reply
  9. kscheer

    5 months ago

    Huberdeu over Reinhart is a joke.

    1
    Reply
    • wreckage

      5 months ago

      10 years over 4 may have something to that evaluation.

      Reply
    • iron

      5 months ago

      Huber over Bure is also a joke. Huber is serviceable, but Bure meant more to the team revitalizing the Panthers in his short time there.

      Reply
    • wreckage

      5 months ago

      Once again, this is strictly based on this millennium. From Jan 1 2000. Bure has played about 150 games in Florida in that time. Huberdeau played almost 700. Guess who left a bigger impact.

      3
      Reply
    • iron

      5 months ago

      If you watched many of those 700 games you would see why he was just about average. NO ONE went to a Panthers game to see Huberdeau. Bure brought back the fans and excitement. I’ll take his 150 games over Huberdeau’s entire career all day.

      2
      Reply
    • wreckage

      5 months ago

      Well it was a poll conducted by the NHL asking former players and team executives and writers and it was based on their input. Clearly the people paid to do hockey stuff disagree with your amateur eye and assessment. The guy who averaged just below a ppg across 10 seasons had a stronger case then the guy with just over a PPG across 2.5 seasons when voting on the teams most influential players of this millennium.

      Reply
    • iron

      5 months ago

      Well these polls are made for inspiring comments…
      Also, have you played against NHL players…No?…I have.

      Reply
    • wreckage

      5 months ago

      Have I played against NHL players? In practice and scrimmage ya, I played vs/with a guy who went 1st round 5th overall, while in high school. Taught me quick that I wasn’t close to good enough to pursue a career playing. Made some acquaintances who work around the game since too. Enough to know guys respect guys with longevity over a short burst in certain situations like this poll. Bure was an amazing player, especially over the entirety of his career. But Huberdeau had a better and more impactful career since Jan 1, 2000 to this date, than Pavel did for the Panthers. Pavel may have been more dazzling and had more superstar sizzle than Huberdeau in the time frame, but Huberdeau had a longer lasting effect in the set time frame than Bure. A better career is another story, Bure owns that, but a more impactful time in Florida since Jan 1, 2000 is another story.

      1
      Reply
    • iron

      5 months ago

      Looks like we agree to disagree. I am glad that we were able to express our opinions. Good to hear that you actually played with an NHL’er. I actually sub’ed a couple of times at Panthers practices and regularly faced NHL players in practice and ex-NHL/WHA players in leagues. Was told by a 50 goal scorer that I would have fit right in the WHA. Wishing you all the best!

      Reply
  10. jminn

    5 months ago

    Come on Josh!! There is no way Fowler beats both Pronger and Beauchemin for the first team. Both are much, much, much better than he.

    Reply
    • wreckage

      5 months ago

      This is the NHL’s evaluation not his.

      1
      Reply
    • Josh Erickson

      5 months ago

      @jminn – this page reflects the final teams as voted on by local media and former players. Looks like they disagree, at least in terms of total impact/longevity.

      2
      Reply
    • jminn

      5 months ago

      Sorry about that Josh. I should have known. I’d still take Prongs or Beauch every day over Fowler.

      Reply
  11. DarkSide830

    5 months ago

    Brandon Montour lol

    Reply
  12. M34

    5 months ago

    Perry over Kariya seems wrong to me.
    Seattle being a part of this list also seems wrong.

    1
    Reply
    • wreckage

      5 months ago

      Kariya only played 3.5 seasons this millennium, Perry played 14 seasons this millennium there. That’s why Perry takes top spot over Kariya.

      4
      Reply
    • M34

      5 months ago

      I suppose. I guess I’m still a bit old school in that sense. I’ll brace myself now to not see forsberg, modano, alfredsson, and all the other guys i grew up watching on the 1st team lists

      1
      Reply
    • PyramidHeadcrab

      5 months ago

      Paul Kariya remains my favourite NHL player of all time. He was so, so fun to watch. They just don’t make ’em like they used to… Probably because Scott Stevens went and showed the league you can basically attempt to kill a guy and get away with it.

      2
      Reply
  13. Bradley B

    5 months ago

    I’m surprised Suter is 2nd team for Minnesota.

    Reply
    • PyramidHeadcrab

      5 months ago

      Suter and Parise were never bad players, they were quite good in fact. They were just overpaid.

      2
      Reply
    • Bradley B

      5 months ago

      I loved them both in those early years. It’s a little nuts that they were top 5 contracts when they were signed, though.

      Reply
  14. 66TheNumberOfTheBest

    5 months ago

    I think they actually got the Pens right.

    Reply
    • bucsfan

      5 months ago

      Yeah I’m happy about Gonchar being first team, although I love Orpik as well. Dumo being the other D-man on the 2nd team was nice.

      While I know the way this was designed, I still feel something wrong about Mario being listed on the 2nd team of anything related to the Pens.

      1
      Reply
  15. M34

    5 months ago

    I forgot about Gonchar. Especially as a penguin

    Reply
  16. aberdeen101

    5 months ago

    LOL with the Malkin over Lemieux comment for Pittsburgh. Most people with a brain know who should be first team between the two.

    Reply
    • wreckage

      5 months ago

      Once again. It’s since the calendar flipped to 2000. Lemuiex was definitely a better player over all. But which one has had a bigger impact since Jan 1, 2000?

      This is why the rest of the world makes fun of the American education system. How many time has it been pointed out that this is a poll from the NHL to players and broadcasters from local markets, people much more wise to to the situation than any of us, who select these teams. Not writers on this site, not fans, not some random writers elsewhere. Former players and beat writers for NHL.

      SMFH at some of the maroons that come into this article.

      2
      Reply
    • Wilf is no longer Kesler

      5 months ago

      It’s not an all-time Pittsburgh team. Simple concept spelled out at the top of the page. The brain people read it.

      Reply
    • foleyd7

      5 months ago

      Agree. I don’t care if Lemieux only played 1 game in this century. The fact that he isn’t 1st team renders this whole exercise irrelevant. Lemieux would be 1st team of ALL TIME.

      Also, in no universe is any winger in Anahiem better than the combined tandem of Selanne and Kariya. Those 2 were so dynamic together that no individual forward from Anahiem touches their impact together.

      Reply
  17. wreckage

    5 months ago

    Pronger, Cechmanek, and Boucher is a joke right?

    Reply
    • Germond

      5 months ago

      Even Boosh was genuinely surprised on yesterday’s telecast.

      1
      Reply
  18. frozenaquatic

    5 months ago

    I can see them not wanting the Carter Hart blowback (his numbers were pretty bad anyway) but no way Boucher should be over Bryzgalov or Steve Mason.

    Reply
    • PyramidHeadcrab

      5 months ago

      Or Bobrovsky??

      Reply
    • frozenaquatic

      5 months ago

      Bob had one good year, his rookie year, with Philly. Boucher had two solid years. Bryzgalov had two good years with the Flyers. Mason had 3 really good years and 1 solid year. Justice for Steve Mason.

      1
      Reply
  19. fightcitymayor

    5 months ago

    Tim Thomas over Tuukka Rask is an eternal debate. TT has the Cup, Rask has the better long-term consistency.

    2
    Reply
    • frozenaquatic

      5 months ago

      Timmy had two Vezinas as well. Tukka never won one.

      Reply
    • fightcitymayor

      5 months ago

      Rask won the Vezina in 2014 (and was runner-up in 2020).

      3
      Reply
    • frozenaquatic

      5 months ago

      I stand corrected. Tukka was very very good.

      Reply
  20. wreckage

    5 months ago

    Hasek? Hasek? He pleyed in Buffalo for 1.5 seasons under the terms expressed.

    2
    Reply
    • PyramidHeadcrab

      5 months ago

      And was one of the best goaltenders the league has ever seen.

      Reply
    • 66TheNumberOfTheBest

      5 months ago

      I thought, “well, maybe they just had nothing but scrubs outside of Ryan Miller” but Marty Biron had a solid run there.

      And Hasek was the best EVER. In the 90’s.

      1
      Reply
    • Nha Trang

      5 months ago

      Yeah, anyone sane would have to put Biron’s seven seasons of very solid play for the Sabres over Hasek’s last single Vezina.

      Reply
  21. PyramidHeadcrab

    5 months ago

    That Buffalo lineup really showcases why they’re such bottom feeders most years…. Lots of good players, but not any real stars outside of the net. 25 years and the best you can show for it is Jason Pominville? Ehhhhhh…

    Then they finally get a star in Eichel, and they trade him away because they didn’t want to approve a procedure to fix his back. Must be so frustrating for those fans.

    1
    Reply
  22. DarkSide830

    5 months ago

    Rask > Thomas

    2
    Reply
  23. M34

    5 months ago

    Lucic over pasta?!?!
    No way

    Reply
  24. jdgoat

    5 months ago

    How do they leave Kari Lehtonen off Dallas while putting Belfour on. I think you could argue he could even be above Turco.

    Reply
    • frozenaquatic

      5 months ago

      I agree! Even Otter is more important than either Belfour (the cup was in the 90s! Followed by two very mediocre seasons) or Turco already if we’re being honest.

      Reply
  25. M34

    5 months ago

    Kinda wierd seeing pavelskis name on a 25 year dallas list.

    Also, Williams’ laundry list of clutch moments puts him on the first team for the canes in my opinion.

    Reply
  26. jdgoat

    5 months ago

    I was kind of surprised to see Oshie on Washingtons list, it seems like he’s only been there for a short period of time. Can’t believe he’s spent the majority of his career there and not in St Louis.

    1
    Reply
  27. frozenaquatic

    5 months ago

    Only quibble with the Habs would be Petry (steady over 7+ seasons) over Souray (one big year), but wow have the Canadiens been pretty bad for 25 years.

    Reply
  28. Gbear

    5 months ago

    These lists are so arbitrary. But whatever.

    1
    Reply
  29. WizofI

    5 months ago

    These lists are based on stats for the last 25 years. An example is Chicago. In no way is Sharp the better player over Hossa in their times with Chicago. Sharp has better stats since he played more games so he is on the 1st team, Hoss on the second.

    Reply
  30. M34

    5 months ago

    Cant really argue with the avalanche list. I suppose you could make a case for J.S. Giguere, but Varly on team 2 is fine as well

    1
    Reply
  31. Macbeth

    5 months ago

    Why is Mario on the second team?

    Reply
    • Rollie's Mustache

      5 months ago

      It does look weird, but the list is limited to the 2000’s. So Mario’s 170 GP and 229 PTS in that timeframe pale in comparison to the contributions of someone on the first team like Guentzel (503 GP, 466 PTS).

      Reply
    • 66TheNumberOfTheBest

      5 months ago

      I think my pro Mario credentials are fairly self evident…

      I can make a solid case for Jordan Staal over Mario based on years that start with a 2.

      1
      Reply
  32. Rollie's Mustache

    5 months ago

    I know the Moore incident overshadowed a lot of what Bertuzzi did in Vancouver, but I think you could make the argument that he deserves a spot on that second team. His line with Naslund and Morrison was truly dominant – like, legitimately the best line in hockey for a time. Bertuzzi finished with more points as a Canuck than Kesler too, although Kesler had more playoff success.

    Maybe I’m biased since I lived in Vancouver during his tenure, but Bert was a real fan favorite there and arguably the best power forward in the game in the early 00’s.

    1
    Reply
    • M34

      5 months ago

      But this is a list of players to represent the team. Bertuzzis execution of one of the dirtiest incidents in the history of the sport is not the type of thing you want representing your franchise.

      Reply
  33. DevilShark

    5 months ago

    The Nico Hischier snub is criminal. More influential than 4 of those forwards over the past 25 years.

    1
    Reply
    • Wilf is no longer Kesler

      5 months ago

      Criminal? Really? This is nothing but an exercise in creating some fantasy lineups. Lighten up a bit. Or a lot.

      Reply
    • DevilShark

      5 months ago

      Or you could have your own opinion and p.o.

      1
      Reply
    • Wilf is no longer Kesler

      5 months ago

      No thanks. More fun to mock anyone who thinks that it is criminal to be missing a guy on what amounts to a fantasy hockey lineup.

      Reply
    • frozenaquatic

      4 months ago

      I don’t have a dog in this fight but I’m pretty sure DevilShark was using a metaphor.

      Reply
    • Wilf is no longer Kesler

      4 months ago

      Maybe. If so, a bad one. Criminal? Worthy of mocking. Also noted that he didn’t claim metaphor status so quite possibly it was standard issue hyperbole, normal stuff by the emotional types who rant around these parts.

      Reply
  34. 66TheNumberOfTheBest

    5 months ago

    I was thinking Joe Nieuwendyk, winning them a Cup and all, but either way…Zajac?

    Reply
  35. Nha Trang

    5 months ago

    Yzerman in the 2000s OVER Fedorov and Shanahan?? AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

    2
    Reply
  36. Josh Erickson

    5 months ago

    Yeah, I feel like these are getting progressively more unhinged

    1
    Reply
    • Nha Trang

      4 months ago

      Mmhmm. This is reminding me suspiciously of all those NHL Best! Of! All! Time! compilations that turn out to REALLY be “best that the 20-something author’s seen with his own eyes,” or “best that the YouTuber can find recent broadcasts to gank clips from.”

      Here, it’s just “Pick the more famous name, even if he only played a handful of games after Y2K.”

      Reply
  37. PyramidHeadcrab

    5 months ago

    Wow, that Islanders list is *brutal*. There have been teams during the last 25 years where none of these players would even make the top line. Same problem as Buffalo – years of mediocrity and no real star power to show for it.

    1
    Reply
  38. wreckage

    5 months ago

    How does an Islanders list not include Tavares? Even if hated, he has to be a top 6 forward there in the 2000s.

    Reply
    • Perreault11

      4 months ago

      If you looked at the list with your eyes open you would see Tavares on the first team.

      1
      Reply
    • junkmale

      4 months ago

      lol and wreckage was never heard from again.

      Also: I’m loving reading some of the comments from fans revisiting the ghosts of fandom past with these lists.

      Reply
  39. DarkSide830

    4 months ago

    Wow, that Rangers 1st team is great, I bet they won many cups!

    1
    Reply
  40. PyramidHeadcrab

    4 months ago

    Ben Bishop over Nikolai Khabibulin? What crack were they smoking for that one?

    Reply
    • FeeltheThunder

      4 months ago

      Before Vasilevskiy, Bishop was the best goalie in Lightning history. He now is second all time in games played (227), starts (223), wins (131) and shutouts (17), but his 2.28 GAA and .921 save percentage are first in Tampa Bay history among goalies to play at least 50 games. Bishop guided the Lightning to the Stanley Cup Final in 2015, winning 13 games with three shutouts, a 2.18 GAA and .921 save percentage in 25 games. Khabibulin despite winning the Cup in ‘04 (unlike Bishop in ‘15) Khabibulin just doesn’t have better numbers overall in his career, hence why Bishop got picked instead. Bishop also mentored Vasilevskiy as well.

      1
      Reply
    • Nha Trang

      4 months ago

      By what possible metric do you imagine that Khabibulin was better? This isn’t a list of “Who played on the most Cup-winning teams.”

      Reply
  41. FeeltheThunder

    4 months ago

    Overall, both Tampa’s 1st & 2nd teams are pretty damn solid.

    Reply
  42. M34

    4 months ago

    Having to pick 2 out of vasy, bishop, and khabibulin is the definition of first world problems.

    2
    Reply
    • FeeltheThunder

      4 months ago

      True

      Reply
  43. 66TheNumberOfTheBest

    4 months ago

    If Mike Fisher is on your first team…couldn’t make most club’s ninth team.

    Also, didn’t Ryan Suter play there…for, like, a decade? Ekholm and Timonen are/were nice players and all, but…

    1
    Reply
  44. Gbear

    4 months ago

    The Preds forward list is a testament at how badly they’ve drafted at that position. Only Legwand was drafted by them out of those 6 players listed. And while they’re all good players in their own right, none of them are elite level.

    Reply
  45. M34

    4 months ago

    Edmontons defensive players on this list make me laugh.

    But LA on the other hand. That’s a good solid list.

    Reply
  46. M34

    4 months ago

    Actually, as I peruse this again, it’s kinda strange that the yotes only had 5 post season appearances in the last quarter century. Their lists are pretty decent

    Reply
  47. jdgoat

    4 months ago

    Dakota Mermis robbed

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

    Top Stories

    Oilers’ Ryan Nugent-Hopkins Uncertain For Game 3

    Maple Leafs Hire Derek Lalonde As Assistant Coach

    Avalanche’s Logan O’Connor Out 5-6 Months Following Hip Surgery

    Lightning Hire Dan Hinote As Assistant Coach

    Stars Fire Pete DeBoer

    Rangers Hire David Quinn, Joe Sacco As Assistant Coaches

    Bruins Name Marco Sturm Head Coach

    Re-Signing Luke Hughes Top Priority For Devils Off-Season

    Penguins Name Dan Muse Head Coach

    Avalanche Sign Brock Nelson To Three-Year Extension

    Recent

    Blue Jackets Notes: Provorov, Danforth, Keskinen

    Lightning Sign Jack Finley To Three-Year Contract

    Sabres Mulling Options As Draft Approaches

    Brad Marchand Discussed Future With Panthers

    2025 NHL Draft Combine Results

    Oilers’ Ryan Nugent-Hopkins Uncertain For Game 3

    Karson Kuhlman Signs With Sweden’s Rögle BK

    Egor Sokolov Linked To CSKA Moscow

    Offseason Checklist: Los Angeles Kings

    Free Agent Focus: Montreal Canadiens

    Rumors By Team

    Rumors By Team

    • Avalanche Rumors
    • Blackhawks Rumors
    • Blue Jackets Rumors
    • Blues Rumors
    • Bruins Rumors
    • Canadiens Rumors
    • Canucks Rumors
    • Capitals Rumors
    • Devils Rumors
    • Ducks Rumors
    • Flames Rumors
    • Flyers Rumors
    • Golden Knights Rumors
    • Hurricanes Rumors
    • Islanders Rumors
    • Jets Rumors
    • Kings Rumors
    • Kraken Rumors
    • Lightning Rumors
    • Mammoth Rumors
    • Maple Leafs Rumors
    • Oilers Rumors
    • Panthers Rumors
    • Penguins Rumors
    • Predators Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Red Wings Rumors
    • Sabres Rumors
    • Senators Rumors
    • Sharks Rumors
    • Stars Rumors
    • Wild Rumors

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • Brock Boeser Rumors
    • Scott Laughton Rumors
    • Brock Nelson Rumors
    • Rickard Rakell Rumors
    • Mikko Rantanen Rumors

    Pro Hockey Rumors Features

    Pro Hockey Rumors Features

    • Support Pro Hockey Rumors And Go Ad-Free
    • 2024-25 Salary Cap Deep Dive Series
    • 2025 NHL Free Agent List
    • 2026 NHL Free Agent List
    • Active Roster Tracker
    • Arbitration-Eligible Free Agents 2025
    • Coaching Staff Directory
    • Draft Order 2025
    • Trade Tracker
    • Pro Hockey Rumors On X
    • Pro Hockey Rumors Polls
    • Waiver Claims 2024-25

     

     

     

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives

    PHR Info

    • About
    • Privacy Policy
    • Commenting Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    Pro Hockey Rumors is not affiliated with National Hockey League, NHL or NHL.com

    scroll to top

    Register

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version