Opportunity Knocks For Ducks’ Lukáš Dostál

John Gibson has become synonymous with Anaheim Ducks goaltending. He’s worked his way into all-time status since taking over the team’s starting role in 2016, with 193 wins, 477 games, and a .910 save percentage through his career – all ranked second on Anaheim’s all-time leaderboards behind Jean-Sebastien Giguere. But for the first time in his career, Gibson is at risk of being dethroned. Star prospect Lukáš Dostál has ascended to Anaheim’s top levels, last season becoming the first Duck besides Gibson to play in 40 or more games since 2016. Dostál stood strong in his chances, while Gibson continued to struggle, opening the door to a full-blown takeover next season.

Dostál has been working towards a coup since well before he moved to California in 2021. The 2018 third-round selection previously had a standout career in Finland’s Liiga – posting 41 wins and a .929 save percentage through 64 career games. That dominance followed him to the AHL, and Dostál quickly planted his stake as a top prospect with 15 wins and a .916 save percentage in his first 24 games with the San Diego Gulls. He’d maintain that save percentage through 40 more AHL games in 2021-22, playing well enough to earn his first NHL call-up. He played in just four games but showed an ability to stand up to the bombardment Anaheim routinely received. That fortitude earned Dostál 19 more NHL games last season and, with continued strong performances, the full-time backup role this year.

Dostál’s slow and steady climb to the top flight lined up with the worst years of Gibson’s career. He allowed a career-high 172 goals-against in 2021-22 – sat behind a Ducks defense that faced an average of 33.2 shots-against per game. It was clear that Gibson couldn’t stand up to the shelling – setting him up horribly for what was about to come, as the 2022-23 Ducks faced a staggering 39.1 shots-against per game: a record in the modern NHL. Gibson, understandably, performed horribly – becoming the first goalie since 2009 to allow 200 goals in one season and posting the first sub-.900 save percentage of his career.

Gibson entered 2023-24 on the heels of that historically-bad Ducks season – matched against Dostál, who was coming off a string of five strong seasons across the hockey world. And while Gibson entered the year as Anaheim’s de facto starter, he failed to maintain the wedge, stacking up 15 losses and a .904 in his first 24 games of the season. Those meager performances, and battles with injury, earned Dostál the lion’s share of ice time in the year’s second-half. His stat line of 15 losses and a .906 in 29 games didn’t jump off the page, though it stood tall compared to the abysmal 12 losses and .870 save percentage that Gibson managed in his final 22 games of the year.

Regardless of the starter, Anaheim’s 2023-24 campaign was underwhelming – with just 27 wins on the year. But it was Dostál who stood up to the test of a full season, while Gibson’s save percentage continued its gradual decline. To add insult to injury, Dostál has spent his summer leading Team Czechia to a World Championship Gold medal – posting a .939 in eight tournament games – while Gibson has once again failed to garner interest on the trade market. It seems Anaheim’s faith sits with the former, though Gibson’s lofty $6.4MM cap hit will command at least a chance at respectable ice time. It might prove his last chance at hanging onto the role he’s carried for the last eight years, though continued struggles could quickly cut things short, especially if Dostál enters the year with the dominance he showed at the World Championship.