With the trade deadline five days away, bubble teams in both conferences are faced with the difficult balance between buying and selling. One such club, the Nashville Predators, have some intriguing assets but as they sit one spot out of a Wild Card spot, it may be a quieter week than fans hope. Insider Elliotte Friedman of Sportsnet discussed the dilemma on last Friday’s episode of 32 Thoughts: The Podcast. With GM Barry Trotz stepping down, and new ownership coming in, throwing in the towel on the season while close to the playoffs may be hard to justify.
The Predators’ most valuable trade asset is likely Ryan O’Reilly. However, as mentioned by Friedman on February 28th’s edition of Saturday Headlines, while teams are trying to tempt Nashville to make a move, they’re treating the veteran Stanley Cup winner with deserved respect, giving him control of the situation. It is thought that O’Reilly does not wish to move.
O’Reilly, 35, plays a vital role on the Predators, leading the team with 57 points in 59 games, a factor on both ends of the ice. Outside of him, Nashville is extremely thin down the middle. Such is an issue which will need to be addressed this summer, but until then, losing him would effectively be a punt on the season. O’Reilly is still signed through next season at a steal of a $4.5MM cap hit, meaning a deal could be revisited this time next year, but now is a time where the Predators could sell at peak value, with a bidding war, and finally committing to a rebuild.
Outside of O’Reilly, Jonathan Marchessault and Steven Stamkos are consistently thrown around. However, just a few days ago, Stamkos emphasized that he has no intention of waiving his no-movement clause. That’s hardly an issue, as the future Hall of Famer just hit the 30 goal mark on the year, already surpassing last year’s 27 total, as Stamkos played in all 82 games. Signed through 2027-28, it’s likely Stamkos will end up somewhere else before he hangs up his skates, but it won’t be now. The 36-year-old is a key leader for the group, performance aside.
Meanwhile, Marchessault would welcome a fresh start. He has just 17 points on the year, the Conn Smythe winner at times deployed alongside fourth line grinders Cole Smith and Michael McCarron. The issue is that the 35-year-old is signed a year longer than Stamkos, at $5.5MM, to go with trade protection. It’s difficult to imagine a scenario where the Predators could get out of the contract without taking back an unfavorable one, nor using their final salary retention spot, due to the contract duration. Even if the return is not pretty, a move would be in their best interest, doing the veteran right and allowing 21-year-old top prospect Joakim Kemell to finally have a chance.
Otherwise, defensemen Nicklaus Perbix has been reported as to having a market, along with Erik Haula, Michael Bunting, and McCarron. While they’d bring considerably less than a player such as O’Reilly, at the very least, Trotz would be wise to cash in on his pending UFA forwards. Keeping all of them, along with Perbix, in the hopes of a playoff run would be shortsighted.
The Predators have a -28 goal differential, sitting with a 27-24-8 record. Even if they can squeak into the playoffs, they’d be rewarded with a match-up against Colorado or Vegas, an uphill battle to say the least.
Never wanting to give up is admirable of Trotz, yet at the same time, his Predators have not won a playoff round since 2018, while also having just one top five selection in the past decade (Brady Martin, 5th, 2025). Throughout his tenure as head coach of the franchise from 1998-2014, Nashville always fought into the playoffs, but were outlasted by franchises with superior talent. Now, those rivals have gone through entire tear downs and rebuilds, setting themselves up for another decade of success while the Predators remain in the murky middle.
Trotz has assembled a deep prospect core which was kick-started by the team’s first wave of selling off, but they still lack the high end talent to get over the hump. It may be an issue left for the next GM to solve. Set to walk away sooner than expected, Trotz is likely tempted by the idea of a storybook ending, but he has the opportunity to taking advantage of a seller’s market and close the book on his 19 years with the organization set up for the future, even if it means hard decisions this week.
Image Credit: Ron Chenoy-Imagn Images
Theyre like 1 point out of a playoff spot, they’re unlikely to drop much lower even if they sell, with Stamkos, Josi, Evangalista, Forsberg, and Saros definitely not going anywhere if they dont trade Marchessault then they should push for a playoff spot, since a top 10 pick is pretty much not happening unless they win a 10 spot jump for the draft lottery, might as well push
Making the playoffs is NOT an accomplishment, If Nashville gets in, They won’t make a bit of noise, They are CLEARLY a seller, Then replace Humpty Dumpty as GM, And Brunette, Then begin the rebuild, They already have some decent young players.