2025 College Free Agency Preview: Goaltenders And Defensemen

As is always the case at this time of year, we’ve seen an influx of collegiate signings in recent weeks which is likely to continue over the next little while.  Generally speaking, college free agents are rarely coming in as impact prospects with high NHL ceilings but it’s an opportunity for teams to add some depth pieces that are further along in their development compared to players coming out of major junior.

We’re changing things up a bit in our annual preview this time around.  Last month, Gabriel Foley took a closer look at the most prominent players from this year’s class.  Meanwhile, we’re breaking down the rest of the class in two separate columns, one for forwards and one for the rest of the unsigned goaltenders and defensemen, the focus of this last piece.

As always, note that not all of these players will sign entry-level contracts as some will ultimately elect to return to college for another season (or more) while quite a few others not on this list have already signed or will sign NHL or AHL deals in the coming weeks.

Goalies

Matt Davis (Denver)

He took over as the starting goaltender last season and led the Pioneers to the NCAA title.  This year, the 23-year-old put up even better numbers and Denver once again made it to the Frozen Four.  While he’s smaller than teams like goalies nowadays (he stands 6’1), the recent track record of success in big games should garner him some interest in free agency.

Cameron Rowe (Western Michigan)

A two-year starter for the Broncos heading into this season, he wound up having to split time this year with Los Angeles prospect Hampton Slukynsky which probably won’t help his value.  Still, the 23-year-old played quite well with a 2.00 GAA and a .924 SV% in his 17 outings while his 6’3 stature helps his appeal as well.

Alex Tracy (Minnesota State Mankato)

The lone goalie to land in the top ten in Hobey Baker voting, Tracy was the CCHA Goalie of the Year following a stellar performance that saw him put up a 1.42 GAA and a .946 SV% along with five shutouts in 38 games; his GAA and SV% led Division I.  However, at 6’0, he’s on the smaller side and we’ve seen smaller Hobey Baker contenders have to settle for AHL contracts before.  Tracy still has a year of eligibility left but his overall value hasn’t been this high before.

Defense

Boston Buckberger (Denver)

After an impressive freshman year, Buckberger showed that his output was no fluke as he landed in the top ten for scoring by a Division I blueliner.  Still just 21, there is still plenty of developmental runway left which should appeal to NHL teams.  However, at 5’11, he’s undersized but Buckberger has shown enough offensively while playing big minutes for a top team that he should be getting some inquiries about leaving with two years of eligibility left.

Frank Djurasevic (Maine)

The decision to transfer after his freshman year at Merrimack was a wise one as he went from a depth role there to a key one at Maine.  He’s a bit of a later bloomer as he played three USHL seasons before going to college but after showing offensive upside at that level, he was in the top 20 for NCAA Division I defenders this season.  A right-shot defender, he could get some interest now but staying in school for one more year might make more sense.

C.J. Foley (Dartmouth)

A lot of what was said about Buckberger could be said here.  He’s an undersized but still-young (21) defender who took a step forward offensively this season with 30 points in 33 games.  He’s only a year removed from being draft-eligible so it would be a bit surprising if he’s signed this spring but his play should have him on the radar after being a unanimous selection to the ECAC’s First-Team All-Conference.

Brandon Holt (Maine)

Holt was on the radar early in the year when he was averaging over a point per game through the first month of the season.  However, he wasn’t able to sustain that over the back half of the season.  That likely takes him off the NHL radar for now but with how strong his start was, you never know.

Jake Livanavage (North Dakota)

One of the youngest players on this list, Liavanage doesn’t turn 21 until next month and was draft-eligible last year.  He had a very impressive freshman year last season but a 5’10 stature likely didn’t help his case.  However, Liavanage flirted with the 30-point mark once again, showing that the strong start wasn’t the outlier.  Like Foley, it would be a bit surprising if he signed so soon after being draft eligible but he should be on more radars now if nothing else.

Michael Mastrodomenico (Notre Dame)

If there’s such a thing as an ‘old 20’, Mastrodomenico might qualify.  Turning 21 next weekend, he has already played three full college seasons and more than doubled his point total from a year ago.  A right-shot defender, the more prudent move for him might be to play his senior season and then test the open market but if nothing else, he’ll be one to keep an eye on next spring.

Ben Robertson (Cornell)

There’s a theme for several players on this list – young and undersized.  This is once again the case for Robertson who was passed up last year in the draft following a quality first NCAA season.  This season, Robertson – who doesn’t turn 21 until September – played at a similar level.  A quality playmaker in the USHL, he’d likely be better off staying in school for at least one more year and hope to take a step forward offensively before looking to sign.  To that end, Mark Divver of the New England Hockey Journal suggests (Twitter link) that Notre Dame, Michigan, and Denver are among the schools interested in him.