Washington Capitals Didn’t “Really Consider” Brooks Orpik Buyout

The Washington Capitals have had an interesting offseason to say the least. Since being knocked out the playoffs by the Pittsburgh Penguins once again, they’ve lost Nate Schmidt to Vegas, Karl Alzner, Kevin Shattenkirk and Justin Williams to free agency, re-signed T.J. Oshie and Evgeny Kuznetsov to monstrous eight-year deals, and traded Marcus Johansson for a couple of draft picks.

Even now they remain in a tough spot cap-wise, with just $8.6MM in room and two key RFAs still to sign. Through all of this, fans have been thinking, writing and even shouting about a move that seemed clear to them: buy out Brooks Orpik. 

The 36-year old Orpik has two years remaining on his current contract with a $5.5MM cap hit, though the actual salary does go down a bit in year two. That deal looked bad from the start when he signed it in 2014, and even worse last year as he dropped to the third pairing and had little impact in the playoffs. His ice time was the lowest it had been in nearly a decade, and it was clear he wasn’t able to contribute the same way anymore.

So why not buy him out? Well, thanks to Greg Wyshynski of Puck Daddy who asked the question and transcribed the answer during a conference call with GM Brian MacLellan earlier today we have the answer:

I don’t know what we really considered that. I thought Orpik had a good year last year. I thought him and [Nate] Schmidt played well together on our third pair. We value what he brings to young defensemen. He was very good for Schmidt, and Schmidt was good for Orpik. We have a bunch of young defensemen that are coming up: 10 or 12 guys that are under 22. They’re all pretty good players. We’re going to value the ability of Orpik to mentor those guys. 

So I didn’t want a buy out on our salary cap going out four years. I didn’t think it made sense for us.

The four years he is referencing is how long the Capitals would’ve been paying out a potential buyout for Orpik. Instead of his $5.5MM hit the next two seasons, a buyout would have cause a $2.5MM cap hit the next two seasons, and a $1.5MM hit the two after that. That does give them savings now, but perhaps not enough to keep Johansson anyway. The now-Devils forward earns $4.6MM the next two seasons.

So it doesn’t look like Orpik is going anywhere, even if the Capitals do get another buyout window later in the summer after finishing their potential arbitration cases. His role on the team will continue to be shepherding in the young defensemen, and teaching them how to work hard enough to stay in the NHL. After all, who wouldn’t look up to a 36-year old defenseman who earned himself a huge contract without much offensive upside. He’s proof that a solid defensive game can keep you around in the NHL, something that every young defenseman needs to learn.